Learning to sing with an app or a singing teacher: The ultimate comparison for beginners

Millions of people worldwide are now choosing to use an app to learn to sing . These digital tools are surprisingly flexible, smart, and effective. Many of the latest singing apps stand out because they use artificial intelligence and advanced algorithms to analyze the voice and provide immediate feedback.

But can these digital tools really replace a real singing teacher?

We would like to examine this question in detail today.

There are numerous smartphone apps you can use to learn to sing, and some of them are even free. Yousician and Simply Sing are two very popular programs. Both were developed "in collaboration with the world's most innovative and experienced music teachers." The basic version of Yousician is free for twenty minutes a day.

The Complete Vocal Technique App (CVT) and other vocal training apps use scientifically proven effective methods and offer a wealth of content, but cost a one-time fee of €69.99. The question remains: Can you really learn well with vocal training software, or do you need a real vocal coach?

Some musicians criticize apps that use gamification elements like points and levels to motivate and retain singing students. Some experts even say that singing apps could be bad for your voice. This article explores the different ways to learn to sing and helps beginners choose between digital tools and personal lessons.

What can a singing app really do?

The technology that powers modern singing apps has advanced significantly in recent years. These digital assistants can analyze your voice and provide you with helpful feedback in real time, thanks to AI and advanced algorithms.

Real-time feedback and pitch analysis

The best singing apps can accurately recognize and quickly analyze sung notes. The smartphone's microphone picks up the sounds and analyzes them. Most apps use color-coded scales to indicate how close or far the note was. In Yousician or Simply Sing, for example, the bars turn green when the note is correct and red when it's wrong. For more precise note recognition, an external microphone is recommended.

Some apps also display the sung notes on a staff or piano keys, which is another useful feature. This quick feedback on pitch, intonation, and rhythm allows students to learn more effectively and see how much they have improved. Some programs even allow users to scroll back on the timeline to review their own singing after they have performed it.

Gamification: Motivation through points and levels

Many singing apps use elements from video games to motivate users in the long term. "Gamification" is the term behind this concept, which aims to make learning more entertaining, fun, and engaging. The SingStar idea is used in apps like Riyaz , Simply Sing , and Yousician . Bars move across the screen in time with the music, and their position indicates the pitch.

Particularly effective are:

• Scoring systems that provide feedback on performance after each exercise
• Stars and badges for particularly good results
• Level systems that offer new challenges with increasing difficulty
• Daily exercise routines that promote habits

The opportunity to see musical progress has been proven to strengthen perseverance and determination.

Limitations become apparent in technique, breathing, and posture

While they excel at what they offer, singing apps definitely have limitations. They can't provide detailed feedback on your technique, breathing, and posture like a professional vocal coach can. Apps can assess pitch very accurately, but they can't tell you your strengths and weaknesses or give you specific exercises to work on to improve them.

Furthermore, direct, human contact offers emotional support and motivation that an app cannot replace. Proper breathing techniques and posture, in particular, are aspects that are difficult to convey in an app. And for technical questions or problems that arise during practice, the quick and precise assistance of a real teacher is lacking.

A quick look at the best apps for learning to sing

The market for singing apps has grown significantly in recent years. But for many who are just starting out, the sheer number of choices can be overwhelming. Here's a list of eight of the best singing apps, along with a brief description of what makes each one stand out.

Why you can trust our test results

As the editor of this article, I can look back on over 15 years as a guitar student and guitarist. During this time, I've not only used guitar apps but also gained experience with most of the available apps, online courses, and tutorials for learning to sing, and I've witnessed the evolution of online resources firsthand. Incidentally, I'm still learning with the Simply Sing and Yousician 🙂

Additionally, our team is always working to provide you with objective rankings and information with complete editorial independence.

We base our content on product data, structured methods, first-person tests, and selected expert opinions to enable you to make informed decisions for your individual singing journey.

Simply Sing: individual voice adjustment

Simply Sing differs from other singing apps because it can adapt to each person's voice. The people who developed the popular Simply Piano and Simply Guitar also produced this software. It promises to make singing easy for everyone.

What the Simply Sing app can do

Simply Sing's main function is to automatically adapt all songs to the user's vocal range . The program determines the vocal range with a simple test and then adjusts all songs accordingly. This technology allows users to hit high notes that would otherwise be impossible.

The app also allows you to go through the lyrics and tells you exactly when to hold the notes and when to breathe. Users can record and listen to their own singing attempts with the integrated audio recorder . This is very useful for evaluating one's own work.

Features that make Simply Sing special

The app's ability to recognize the user's voice type and offer a personalized singing experience is truly impressive. While some users on forums like Reddit note that the voice recognition isn't always accurate, the ability to sing songs within one's own vocal range is still an extremely useful tool.

The user interface is easy to use, as it intuitive and offers clear menu options such as "For You," "Search," " Playlists," and "Learn." The program also gives you real-time feedback on how well you are singing the notes.

Advantages and disadvantages of Simply Sing

Advantages:

• Intuitive and user-friendly operation
• All songs can be sung in your personal key
• Improving accuracy through play
• Real-time feedback while singing

Disadvantages:

• Very limited free access with no possibility of even singing a single song in its entirety
• Relatively high price without sufficient testing opportunity
• Limited song library with approximately 50 tracks
• Partially unreliable tone recognition and timing problems

Pricing

In Germany, Austria, and Switzerland, the app costs €17.99 per month or €69.99 per year. However, some users online report seeing different prices. Some even say they see offers of €19.08 per month or even lower offers of €4.77 per month when paying a year in advance. This suggests that the provider has implemented some kind of price adjustment system. We were unable to definitively determine which factors influence the repricing. It might also be worth keeping an eye out for deals Black Friday

The free version allows you to determine your vocal range and do some simple vocal exercises. You cannot listen to full songs.

Who is Simply Sing suitable for?

Simply Sing is best for people who like to sing in a comfortable key without straining their voice. The app is great for people who already know and appreciate other Simply products

The software is intended more for those who want to enjoy singing than for people who want to learn how to sing like a professional. One user summed it up like this:

The app is more than karaoke, but less than a full singing course

View inside the app

Yousician: structured learning that's fun

Yousician is an interactive vocal software based on a simple yet powerful idea: it listens to you sing and instantly tells you how well you're hitting the right notes and staying in time. The app is like a virtual vocal coach, showing you how to sing each note and helping you become more proficient.

According to its website, Yousician was developed "in collaboration with the world's most innovative and experienced music teachers." vocal training, the app allows users to learn various instruments.

What the Yousician Sing App can do

Yousician 's technology uses your device's microphone to analyze your singing. This allows you to instantly see if you're singing in time and hitting the right notes. This real-time feedback is key to your learning success.

A group of music teachers designed the learning path for Yousician Sing. It contains everything you need to know to become a good singer. The software shows you how to sing from the very first notes to more complex and lively melodies.

Special features

There are several topics for each class, such as resonance, breathing technique, pitch, rhythm, and delivery. Video introductions, activities, and practice exercises are all part of each lesson. The "steady tone" exercise is particularly helpful because it teaches you how to make your voice sound powerful.

You progress along the learning path by completing missions, which are groups of songs, video tutorials, and games that teach you the skills you need to complete the mission.

For the best voice quality, we recommend connecting an external microphone.

Motivation remains high through gamification, with a points system, star ratings, leaderboards, and progress tracking. Studies suggest that such game features can increase people's interest by up to 80%.

The following features are quite useful:

• Setting the tempo : You can change the tempo yourself or use the auto-tempo mode, which adjusts the speed based on how well you sing (between 25% and 125%).
• Pitch adjustment : You can change the pitch of a song using the transpose tool.
• Practice sections : You can repeat difficult parts by adjusting the sliders.

The huge song library contains hundreds of well-known songs in a variety of styles and difficulty levels. This makes learning fun for a long time.

Advantages and disadvantages of Yousician

Advantages:

• Motivating gamification through playful elements
• Real-time voice feedback via colored bars enables continuous improvement
• Impressive selection of classic and modern songs
• Available for multiple instruments and in multiple languages

Disadvantages:

• Advanced singers notice over time that the feedback is less nuanced than in individual lessons
• Occasional issues with microphone sensitivity – background noise can affect accuracy
• Some users criticize the "streak" concept, which they believe may rely more on guilt than genuine motivation

Pricing and Costs

The free version of Yousician gives you a good first impression, but it has significant limitations. This version is suitable for testing the app before paying for a subscription.

With the Premium subscription, which costs €19.99 per month with monthly billing, you can take all courses, but only for one instrument. This is perfectly sufficient for people who only want to learn to sing. With the Premium+ subscription, at approximately €29.99 per month, you can use all instruments with Yousician , such as guitar, piano, bass, and ukulele. You also get a larger collection of songs, including popular tracks.

The Premium+Family package costs approximately €44.99 per month and allows up to four people to create their own profiles and track their individual progress.

Paying annually saves you 50%.

Who is Yousician suitable for?

The fun elements and immediate feedback keep learners motivated for longer periods, which is difficult to achieve when practicing alone. This gamification has motivated numerous aspiring singers to embark on a learning journey with this app.

Beginners especially benefit from the pedagogically designed and playfully implemented learning app. Yousician is also very suitable for people who want to learn to play an instrument (e.g., guitar or piano) in addition to singing.

View inside the app

Complete Vocal Technique (CVT) app

One of the most effective methods to train your singing voice is the Complete Vocal Technique (CVT). Cathrine Sadolin this new vocal technique , and she has helped professional singers all over the world for the past 25 years.

What the Complete Vocal Technique App can do

The CVT app gives you access to the full spectrum of this renowned vocal method in digital form. The software includes more than 320 chapters covering every aspect of vocal technique . Users can listen to approximately 950 audio examples , accessible for both male and female voices. These audio examples demonstrate how to successfully complete each exercise and help you understand the underlying theory.

The simplified visuals , featuring 309 different images covering everything from anatomy to workout ideas, are incredibly helpful. The app also includes 68 videos from research projects that you can watch offline. The integrated tools demonstrate how the vocal tract works and which muscles are used when singing.

Unique aspects of the Complete Vocal Technique

CVT's scientific approach is one of its most outstanding features. The strategy is based on the latest studies in voice science, anatomy, and physiology . This enables singers to produce any desired sound safely.

The approach works for all types and genres of music , so it can be used with any kind of music. Another aspect that makes this program stand out is its focus on the four singing modes, speaking methods, and the application of various voice effects.

The “CVT Audio Analysis Library” is also available via the CVT app. It contains reference examples from public recordings with precise timecodes. This will help you better understand the theoretical concepts.

Advantages and disadvantages of Complete Vocal Technique

Advantages:

• Comprehensive approach with over 320 chapters
• Scientifically sound method
• Simple explanations with visual aids
• Regular updates with the latest research findings
• Suitable for all singing styles and levels

Disadvantages:

• Currently available primarily in English
• No search function, which makes navigation difficult
• Without teachers, personal feedback is lacking
• Can be overwhelming for beginners
• No quick success with independent learning

Pricing

You can purchase the full version of the CVT app for €69.99. All future updates are included in this price. There's also a free introductory edition with 27 chapters, 68 sound examples, and 6 images. You can identify the free version by its white logo. You can use this basic version to try things out.

The app has the advantage of being frequently updated and adding new information immediately, unlike the printed book. The app has replaced the book, therefore there will be no further updated editions.

Who is Complete Vocal Technique suitable for?

The CVT app is for singers of all levels, from beginners to experts. It's also quite useful for people who already have some singing experience and want to improve their skills.

The CVT app is a great resource for anyone to learn more about a particular singing style . However, experts recommend using the software in conjunction with training from a certified CVT instructor. Without feedback from a tutor, the complex material could quickly become overwhelming.

The program is best suited for singers who are comfortable with technology, appreciate science, and are willing to invest a lot of time and effort to learn more about the subject.

View inside the app

Vox Tools

Vox Tools was developed by qualified speech-level singing teachers and includes a whole range of exercises specifically for singers. This software uses scientific knowledge about the human voice to help people learn how to use it effectively.

What the Vox Tools app can do

The main feature of this app is that it fully guided training with programs from vocal coaches in the Vox Voice Studio. There are many audio examples for both male and female voices . Users can film themselves and listen to the recordings later. The built-in virtual piano is quite useful for practicing.

Vox Tools allows you to precisely select your voice type , making the training much more accurate and tailored to you. The exercises range from simple warm-up exercises and scales to more challenging techniques like vibrato.

What makes Vox Tools special

The app has a simple user interface but offers detailed explanations of the exercises. These not only show you how to perform the exercises but also explain why each one is important. Users can choose between guided training, which includes carefully planned exercise routines, and free training.

Advantages and disadvantages of Vox Tools

Advantages:

• The exercises are precisely described and explained
• Clear app design
• Various exercise categories to choose from
• Developed by experienced vocal teachers

Disadvantages:

• Currently only available in English
• No professional feedback for review
• Requires at least basic English skills

Pricing

The basic version of Vox Tools is free to use. The premium version with additional features costs a one-time fee of €19.99.

Who is Vox Tools suitable for?

The app is particularly suitable for singers looking for specific exercises that go beyond scales. The personalized selection of voice type benefits both beginners and advanced singers. However, users should have a basic knowledge of English, as the detailed explanations cannot be fully utilized otherwise.

View inside the app

Voxercise

Voxercise is a simple yet effective vocal training tool that helps both beginners and advanced users with their daily practice. Many professional singers have used this app and talked about it on Instagram, which has contributed to its popularity.

Features of the Voxercise app

The main purpose of this software is to assist with daily practice by warm-up exercises , scale and arpeggio , riffs , and runs . Users can choose between piano or vocal accompaniment and define their own vocal range. The program also listens to the notes you sing through the microphone and displays them as sheet music and on piano keys.

The app gives you instant pitch feedback , which is very helpful. It tells you immediately whether you've hit the right note or if you're singing too low or too high. Users can also create their own playlists, making their personalized practice routine easy to find.

Special features of voxercise

The user interface is intentionally simple and very clear, making the software user-friendly. The additional videos are particularly helpful, as they teach important basics and demonstrate how to perform the exercises correctly.

Advantages and disadvantages of voxercise

Advantages:

• Clean, professional user interface
• Suitable for beginners and advanced users alike
• Immediate feedback on pitch accuracy
• Ability to create personalized exercise programs

Disadvantages:

• Slightly more expensive compared to other apps
• Available in English only
• Full functionality is only available after purchasing the packages

Prices for Voxercise

The software has a trial version with three exercises and an explanatory video. However, to use all features, you need to purchase additional modules. Each exercise package costs €5.49. Those wishing to purchase all four packages at once must pay a one-time fee of €14.99.

Who is voxercise suitable for?

The app is great for people who want to sing every day. It looks neat and professional, which is especially appealing to those who value clarity. However, users should be aware that they need a basic understanding of English, as it is not available in German. Therefore, Voxercise is suitable for both beginners who want to improve their singing skills and more advanced users who want to learn systematically.

View inside the app

Sawti

Sawti is a singing app from Vienna, developed with the help of Prof. Gerald Wirth , the director of the Vienna Boys' Choir. It's an entertaining way to learn to sing, especially for children and beginners.

What the Sawti app can do

Sawti's main feature is based on the "Hit the Bars" concept. In this case, a small ball moves in real time in sync with the user's voice. Beginners start by learning individual notes and then progress to short phrases, melodies, and rhythm exercises. After an initial recording to determine pitch, each training session is customized for every user, allowing them to see immediate results. The app also includes a practice area where you can try out different singing styles without being judged.

Unique features

The app's educational background Wirth Method , a well-known music education method that lends itself well to vocal training. Sawti also has an interesting story: its name means "my voice" , and it was developed as part of a project to support refugee children in Jordan, funded by the EU and the Austrian Ministry of the Interior. Sawti differs from other singing apps in that it issues you a certificate upon completion of all the exercises.

Advantages and disadvantages of Sawti

Advantages:

• Simple, intuitive operation without registration
• Real-time feedback on pitch and rhythm
• A playful approach with gamification elements
• Scientifically sound methodology from a renowned music educator

Disadvantages:

• Limited selection of exercises in the free version
• Less comprehensive than specialized tech apps
• Designed primarily for beginners, less so for advanced users
• Limited song selection (e.g., Glockenjodler, Old MacDonald)

Pricing

You can get the first three levels for free. You need to pay a one-time fee of €19.99 to get full access to all nine levels.

Who is Sawti suitable for?

Sawti is great for people who are "starting from scratch" and have never done anything like this before. Kindergarten teachers, primary school teachers, music school teachers, choir singers, karaoke fans, parents, and children are all people who might be interested. The software is great for people who want to learn how to sing in a fun way without getting bogged down in complicated theory.

Thomas Buchstätter from PhonicScore adds: "We have already done a lot if this helps more children to enjoy singing again."

View inside the app

Smule – vocal training, karaoke and social network

Smule is one of the most popular karaoke and singing apps in the world. It combines vocal training with a social network in a way no other app does. This app has been downloaded more than 100 million times, meaning it will always be among the top apps on the Google Play Store.

What the Smule app can do

Smule lets you sing along to over 10 million karaoke songs with lyrics . The software allows you to record in various ways: you can sing alone, with a partner, or in a group. One of its best features is that you can sing along to recordings by famous artists like Dua Lipa, LEA, or Ed Sheeran.

The software features professional recording tools that allow you to add extra vocal effects and correct pitch . While you sing, bars similar to those in SingStar show how well you're hitting the notes. Users can also film their performances and then add video effects, animated fonts, and filters.

What makes Smule unique?

Smule differs from other learning apps in that paying users can "open" songs and record the first vocal track, while other users, even those who don't pay, can find these songs and add the second vocal track. This type of collaboration allows singers from all over the world to compose music together .

Smule also has a vibrant community with more than 50 million monthly users. The app has a newsfeed, likes, and follower features, just like Instagram for musicians .

Advantages and disadvantages of Smule

Advantages:

• Huge library with 10 million different songs
• Option to sing in duets or in groups
• Playful improvement of intonation
• Pitch correction and effects for better recordings

Disadvantages:

• No professional feedback on vocal technique
• In the free version, only songs that have already been opened can be completed
• VIP membership required for full functionality
• Focus more on fun than on systematic training

How much does Smule cost?

A one-year subscription to the VIP version of Smule costs €39.99. The cheapest way to subscribe is through the Smule website. Purchasing through the Apple App Store or Google Play Store costs slightly more due to additional fees.

In short, Smule can be used indefinitely without a VIP subscription, but there are some limitations. For example, users cannot open their own songs or sing entirely on their own without VIP.

Who is Smule suitable for?

Smule is great for people who love to sing and meet new people. The software is also great for anyone who wants to discover which genres of music they enjoy.

But Smule isn't really designed for regular vocal training. "Learning to sing happens almost incidentally in this app," as one expert rightly points out. So, for people who simply want to improve their singing, specialized learning apps are a better choice.

View inside the app

SwiftScales

Singers SwiftScales for singers, and it's the first app that makes you feel like you're sitting with a pianist . This virtual vocal coaching program is a great way for both beginners and experienced singers to practice.

What the SwiftScales app can do

SwiftScales offers practice sessions for all skill levels , from beginners to experts. The software adapts in real time, moving with the user regardless of how high or low, fast or slow they sing. The dashboard is particularly useful. Despite its simple name, it contains valuable information about the voice, vocal cords, and range, as well as breath and pitch training .

There is a sound reference for each workout so users know how it should sound. Additionally, you can use pre-made routines tailored to the individual's vocal range.

Unique Features

One outstanding feature is the ability to create your own exercises and share your routines with other users . You can share your training plans with others via the cloud-sharing tool. The app also offers video tutorials that explain in great detail how to use it, as well as help on every page.

Advantages and disadvantages of SwiftScales

Advantages:

• Complete control over training sessions in real time
• Professionally recorded audio examples
• No prior musical knowledge required
• Extensive customization options

Disadvantages:

• The app directly asks for gender and voice range, which can be problematic for beginners
• Sound references are demonstrated with glottal stop
• Menu names are not always intuitive

Pricing

You can use most features for free, but they are ad-supported. You need to make a one-time in-app purchase to unlock additional features without ads. You only need to pay 29.90 RM (approximately 6–7 euros) once for the Pro version.

Who is SwiftScales suitable for?

SwiftScales is suitable for both new and experienced users. Singing teachers can also use the app to help their students practice techniques they already know. The software is especially useful for people who want to create their own practice routines or are looking for an app that functions like a real piano, allowing them to change tempo, pitch, and volume.

View inside the app

ScatAbility: specifically for scat singing

ScatAbility differs from other singing apps because it focuses on scat singing , a type of jazz singing that uses syllables instead of words to create melodies. This program works by having you listen and then imitate what you hear, which is also how you learn a foreign language.

What the ScatAbility app can do

The app has three types of exercises: Exercises , Etudes , and Call & Response . Users can practice with well-known professional jazz singers such as Michele Weir, Darmon Meader, and Rosana Eckert. A useful feature is the ability to mute the vocal track and experiment with the accompaniment tracks. You can also export all your recordings .

The free basic version comes with seven tracks, "Scat Pack 0" . Each track contains a sung scat solo that you can use as a guide. The loop function allows you to practice specific parts repeatedly.

What makes ScatAbility unique

The detailed information section , which explains style, tempo, key, and instrumentation, is very helpful. Chord progressions are displayed in real time as you play. The app also has a long list of jazz terms in its glossary.

Advantages and disadvantages of ScatAbility

Advantages:

• No prior knowledge of jazz theory is required
• Professionally recorded demos
• Flexible practice options thanks to mixer functions

Disadvantages:

• There are no written solos; one has to rely on one's ear
• Clearly designed for advanced users
• It does not replace the usual learning methods for improvisation

How much does ScatAbility cost?

The basic version is free. Additional practice packs, each containing five more songs, cost €10.99.

Who is ScatAbility suitable for?

ScatAbility is primarily for people who want to become jazz singers and already know a lot about it. But the app takes an immersive approach, meaning it can also be used by people who don't know much about theory. The program was originally developed for personal use, but can also be used in the classroom for music lessons.

View inside the app

Comparison table

App Name	Main functions	Special features	Price	Target audience	Language
Complete Vocal Technique (CVT)	– 320+ chapters on vocal technique – 950 audio examples – 309 illustrations – 68 research videos	– Scientific approach – Suitable for all music styles – CVT Audio Analysis Library	€69.99 (one-time fee)	Singers of all levels, especially those with prior experience	English
Simply Sing	– Automatic pitch adjustment – ​​Scrolling lyrics – Audio recorder – Real-time feedback	– Personalized singing experience – Playful structure	€17.99/month or €69.99/year	Amateur singer	German, English, French, Spanish, Italian, etc.
Smule	– 10 million karaoke songs – Solo, duet and group recordings – Pitch correction – Video effects	– Social platform – Collaboration with other singers – 50 million monthly users	€39.99/year	Amateur singers, socially oriented users	German, English, French, Spanish, Italian, etc.
Yousician	– Voice adjustment – ​​Real-time feedback – Modern song selection	– Motivating gamification – Learning multiple tools	from €9.99/month	Beginners and advanced learners	German, English, French, Spanish, Italian, etc.
Vox Tools	– Guided training – Recording function – Virtual piano	– Developed by certified vocal coaches – Detailed exercise explanations	€19.99 (one-time fee)	Beginners and advanced learners	English
Voxercise	– Warm-ups – Exercises on arpeggios and scales – Real-time feedback	– Simple, clear interface – Supplementary instructional videos	€14.99 (one-time fee for all packages)	Beginners and advanced learners	English
SwiftScales	– Built-in practice sessions – Real-time adjustments – Sound references	– Cloud sharing for exercise routines – Video tutorials	6-7 € (one-time fee)	Beginner to expert	English
ScatAbility	– Three exercise types – Backing tracks – Loop function	– Focus on jazz vocals – Professional demo recordings	Basic version free, additional packs €10.99 each	Jazz singer with prior experience	English
Sawti	– “Hit the beams” concept – Individually adapted exercises – Rehearsal room function	– Based on the Wirth method – Certification upon completion	€19.99 (one-time fee)	Absolute beginners, children	German

Singing lessons with a real teacher: advantages and disadvantages

Singing apps are useful digital tools, but there are advantages conventional singing lessons from a real person that no app can offer. For many singers, the personal contact and experience of a vocal coach cannot be replaced.

Individual feedback and correction

Singing teachers can give you objective feedback on your voice, something apps can't. A trained ear from the outside is very helpful because we hear ourselves singing differently than others perceive us.

A skilled teacher can recognize both tonal and physical errors, such as posture, facial expression, and stress patterns. A teacher can provide feedback on how you play music and help you develop your own style, which is different from apps.

Breath control, technique and posture

When you sing, your posture, breathing, and sound are significantly interconnected. A vocal coach not only teaches you the fundamentals of how the voice works and how to use it, but also helps you correct poor posture.

Personal lessons focus on teaching correct breathing technique abdominal-lateral breathing . This biologically correct method prevents long-term vocal damage and prepares the voice for the demands of singing.

Emotional support and motivation

The mental aspect of singing is truly significant. When students reach their limits, a sensitive vocal coach there for them emotionally. Letting go of expectations and finding a balance between tension and relaxation are both essential for healthy singing. For shy individuals, having a supportive teacher can often be invaluable in overcoming their emotional blocks.

Prices and availability

The most obvious drawback of singing lessons is the higher cost. Prices vary somewhat, but typically range from €27 to €100 per hour. With weekly private lessons, expenses can quickly climb to €6,000 per year. However, many music schools offer flexible options, such as contracts that can be cancelled monthly or lessons that don't require a fixed contract. For beginners, one hour per week is usually sufficient. More advanced students, however, will benefit from more than one session per week.

Lessons with a teacher cost more than a singing app, but they also offer much more support. Ultimately, the choice between an app and a teacher depends on your own goals, your budget, and how quickly you want to learn.

When is which learning method more suitable?

Here are some things to consider when choosing between a singing app and traditional singing lessons. There's a perfect path for every type of singer that best suits their individual needs.

For beginners: Should I choose an app or a teacher?

The most fundamental question for beginners is generally "App or teacher?" Singing apps have many advantages for people who are just starting out. They make it easier to get started without the pressure of having to perform and allow people to learn at their own pace . The immediate visual feedback on pitch and rhythm can be very helpful in learning how to use one's voice.

But apps can't detect all the critical details. A vocal coach can identify each student's strengths and areas for improvement, and then provide them with tailored exercises. Furthermore, a coach can demonstrate proper breathing and posture, which is difficult to achieve with an app.

For more advanced students: a mixture of both approaches

Advanced singers generally benefit most from using both methods together . The best way to learn to sing online is to take pre-recorded video courses and receive individual coaching from a professional trainer. This way, you can get crucial personalized feedback while still having the freedom to navigate the digital learning environment.

Singing apps are a great supplement to regular classes, but they shouldn't replace them. They're great for practicing what you've learned between classes and making sure you retain it.

Weighing costs, time investment and learning progress

The following aspects are key when choosing the right method:

• Budget : Singing lessons can quickly become expensive, but apps are a more affordable option. Therefore, the monthly budget for singing lessons is the most important factor.
• Time flexibility : Apps offer a flexible way to practice for people who are constantly on the go or have a lot to do.
• Learning style : Some people learn more diligently when they work together with others, while others learn better when they work alone.

Also consider what singing means to you personally. People who make singing a regular part of their lives become more proficient faster, regardless of the method they use.

Concluding thoughts

Ultimately, it's safe to say that both singing apps and traditional lessons have their specific advantages and disadvantages. Apps are definitely an affordable and easy way to get started with singing. The fun approach and instant pitch feedback are very helpful for beginners. But when it comes to individual technique, breath control, and emotional support, these digital tools have clear limitations.

On the other hand, personal singing lessons offer something no app can give you: a real person. An outstanding teacher not only points out technical flaws but also helps you find your own musical voice. But this individual help costs money and time.

There's no single answer to the question, "App or teacher?" The optimal answer depends on your specific goals, your budget, and your individual learning style. For many people, the ideal way to learn is to take regular lessons with a vocal coach while also practicing daily with an app in between.

No matter which path you choose, one thing is always true: you must be patient, keep trying, and practice singing regularly. Long-term success comes from giving your voice time to grow and celebrating small victories. Apps can help organize and motivate the process, and a teacher can provide specific help and corrections along the way.

Ultimately, singing isn't just about having great technique; it's also about finding joy in how you express yourself. Anyone who thinks this way, whether they use an app, a teacher, or both, will find their own way to improve their voice.

Our testing methodology and Kunstplaza's self-understanding of honest reviews

Finally, we would like to share a few lines About us self-image regarding honest, helpful and authentic test reports.

Which guidelines are we committed to:

• Complete weighing of all pros and cons
• Clarification and naming of the facts
• Reliable research (two-source principle where possible) and own test run ( first-hand experience )
• Authentic opinion (if we were to use the provider ourselves)
• Dealing with user criticism from review platforms
• Naming alternatives
• Transparency regarding remuneration and financing (see affiliation note at the bottom)
• Avoidance of economic directives and dependence on the mentioned providers