Draft cultural heritage protection law turns the art world upside down

“Cultural Heritage Protection Act” : A weighty term that doesn't immediately reveal its full implications to the uninformed reader. Behind it lies a controversial idea, the content of which is currently provoking vehement resistance from the art world.

The extent of the current debate clearly demonstrates the importance attached to this planned amendment to the law, and can be followed live #Kulturgutschutzgesetz

The planned cultural heritage protection law proposed by Minister of State for Culture Grütters is essentially a modernization of the existing cultural heritage protection law . Although the idea behind the law is, according to BR journalists and art expert Stefan Mekiska, actually honorable, it is causing a major uproar in the art world and encountering considerable resistance from dealers, collectors, and artists.

It aims to keep cultural assets of national importance within the country. However, there is a risk that this will restrict the freedom of cross-border exchange.

The following articles will explain the topic and its controversial aspects in more detail and summarize the key points:

1) tagesschau.de: Dispute over cultural heritage protection law – exodus for the German art scene?

Expropriation of artists – or necessary protection of national cultural heritage? Opinions are divided on the planned reform of the Cultural Heritage Protection Act.

When one of Germany's most renowned contemporary artists demands the return of works he has loaned to German museums, the outrage is bound to be considerable. The painter Georg Baselitz is doing just that, and other artists and art patrons intend to follow his example – in protest against the planned reform of the Cultural Heritage Protection Act. They fear losing the rights to their works.

The trigger is the plans of Minister of State for Culture Monika Grütters (CDU), who wants to regulate cross-border trade in art and cultural goods more strictly and adapt it to EU law.

Now, Minister of State for Culture Grütters has defended her plans. […]

tagesschau.de explains what the dispute is about.

Here's a direct link to the original article: tagesschau.de/inland/kulturgutschutzgesetz-101.html

2) Bavarian Broadcasting: Cultural Heritage Protection Act – Art dealers in panic

It's a political statement: Painter Georg Baselitz is withdrawing his loaned works from German museums. The reason is the modernization of the cultural heritage protection law. It's causing an uproar in the art world – including in Bavaria.

A “violation of the constitution,” a “creeping expropriation,” and a “blatant injustice.” Konrad Bernheimer, one of Europe’s most renowned art dealers, speaks with blunt candor when he discusses the planned amendment to the Cultural Heritage Protection Act. […]

Here's a direct link to the original article: br.de/nachrichten/kultur-gut-schutz-gesetz-102.html

3) RP Online: Analysis – Draft law outrages the art scene

The proposed cultural heritage protection law is facing resistance from dealers, collectors, and artists. It aims to keep cultural assets of national importance within the country. However, there is a risk that this will restrict the freedom of cross-border exchange. […]

Here's a direct link to the original article: rp-online.de/kultur/gesetzentwurf-empoert-die-kunstszene-aid-1.5236950

4) FAZ: Cultural Heritage Protection Act – Who is actually being harmed?

The art world is in an uproar. Because a cultural heritage protection law is being planned, Georg Baselitz is withdrawing works from German museums. Gerhard Richter and the descendants of Max Beckmann are considering similar steps. How important are long-term loans? […]

Here's a direct link to the original article: faz.net/aktuell/feuilleton/kunst/schreckgespenst-kulturgutschutzgesetz-13703026.html

5) Süddeutsche Zeitung: Cultural Heritage Protection Act – All clear for artists and collectors

Minister of State Monika Grütters rejects criticism of the cultural heritage protection law. Nevertheless, some initial changes are being implemented: the state will no longer inspect private residences.

The new cultural heritage protection law, currently still a draft bill undergoing inter-ministerial review, has triggered a massive, almost seething, uproar. Minister of State for Culture Monika Grütters, who has been strongly advocating for the amendment for weeks, is clearly not taking the protests lightly.

At a press conference on Wednesday, she defended the law once again, but despite her determination, she made it clear how much the criticism affected her. […]

Here's a direct link to the original article: sueddeutsche.de/kultur/kulturstaatsgesetz-entschaerft-entwarnung-fuer-kuenstler-und-sammler-1.2567005

What's your opinion?

We also greatly appreciate your contributions, remarks and comments 🙂 Simply use our convenient comment function below…

Joachim Rodriguez y Romero

Owner and Managing Director of Kunstplaza . Publicist, editor, and passionate blogger in the fields of art, design, and creativity since 2011. Graduated with a degree in web design from university (2008). Further developed creative techniques through courses in freehand drawing, expressive painting, and theatre/acting. Profound knowledge of the art market gained through years of journalistic research and numerous collaborations with key players and institutions in the arts and culture sector.

www.kunstplaza.de